TOP 10 Reasons you’re not getting recruited

“Everybody’s path to a college baseball scholarship is different. Don’t compare yours to someone else’s.” -Andy Kiriakedes, emd baseball consulting

Introduction: If you’re a high school baseball athlete with dreams of playing at the collegiate level, getting a college baseball offer is likely one of your top priorities. However, the road to earning that offer can be challenging, and there are many factors that can prevent you from achieving your goal. In this post, we’ll discuss the top 10 reasons why you may not be getting a college baseball offer, and what you can do to address each issue.

1 – Coach is not working on your graduate year

One of the most common reasons why high school baseball athletes don’t receive college offers is simply because the college coach is not yet working on their graduate year. Coaches typically focus on recruiting athletes who will graduate in the next year or two, and may not have started scouting players who are several years away from graduating. If you’re a younger player and haven’t yet received any interest from college coaches, don’t be discouraged. Keep working hard and developing your skills, and make sure to reach out to coaches to introduce yourself and express your interest in playing for their program.

2 – You don’t have measurements

College coaches rely heavily on player measurements to make informed recruiting decisions. Without a complete set of measurements, coaches will not be able to accurately assess an athlete’s potential and compare them to other players. As a result, it’s crucial for high school baseball athletes to provide accurate and comprehensive measurements in order to increase their chances of receiving a college scholarship offer.


3 – Your measurements are not at the level of the conference the school plays in

College baseball is a highly competitive sport, and coaches are often looking for athletes who meet specific size and skill requirements. If your measurements (such as height, weight, or throwing velocity) are not at the level expected for the conference the school plays in, it may be more difficult to earn a spot on the team. However, this doesn’t mean that you should give up on your dreams – instead, focus on improving your physical abilities through strength and conditioning training.

4 – College season has started & coach is very busy

Once the college baseball season starts, coaches become very busy with their current players and may not have as much time to focus on recruiting. If you’re not receiving much interest from coaches during the season, don’t take it personally – it may simply be a matter of timing. Instead, try to attend summer camps or showcases where you can showcase your skills to coaches during the off-season.

5 – School is out of scholarship money

Another factor that can impact your chances of receiving a college baseball offer is scholarship availability. If the school you’re interested in has already allocated all of its scholarship funds, they may not be able to offer you any financial aid to attend. While this can be disappointing, it’s important to remember that there are other options available, such as walk-on opportunities or attending a junior college with the goal of transferring to a four-year university later.

6 – You are not ready yet

If you’re not receiving any offers from college coaches, it’s possible that you’re simply not ready yet. This could mean that you need to work on improving your skills, getting stronger, or developing better game sense. Take an honest look at your game and identify areas where you can improve, then work hard to address those weaknesses.

7 – School has already recruited your position

Sometimes, college coaches may not offer you a spot on their team simply because they’ve already recruited someone else for your position. While this can be frustrating, it’s important to remember that there are many factors that go into a coach’s recruiting decisions, and it’s not necessarily a reflection of your abilities as a player. Instead, consider exploring other schools or positions where you may have a better chance of earning a spot.

8 – Your social media profiles scared the school away

In today’s digital age, college coaches often look at social media profiles when considering potential recruits. If your profiles contain inappropriate or controversial content, it may turn off coaches and hurt your chances of receiving an offer. Make sure to keep your profiles clean and professional, and avoid posting anything that could be seen as disrespectful or offensive.

9 – Your grades are not consistent with school expectations

Another important factor that college coaches consider when recruiting athletes is academic performance. If your grades are not consistent with the school’s expectations, it may be more difficult to receive a college baseball offer. Coaches want to recruit athletes who are not only talented on the field but also demonstrate academic success and dedication to their education. Make sure to focus on your studies and maintain a strong GPA, as this can help demonstrate your commitment to your academic goals and increase your chances of receiving a college offer.

10 – The Coach is just not ready yet

Sometimes, coaches may not be ready to offer a spot to a recruit until they’ve had a chance to see more of their performance or receive additional information about their abilities. In this case, it’s important to be patient and continue to work hard to develop your skills. Keep in touch with the coach and let them know of your continued interest in the program, and be sure to attend any camps or showcases they may offer to demonstrate your abilities.

ONE LAST POSSIBLE REASON: Coaches need more information on you and want you to attend one of their camps

Lastly, coaches may want to see more of your performance or get a better sense of your abilities before offering you a spot on their team. In this case, attending one of their camps or showcases can be a great way to demonstrate your skills and showcase your potential as a recruit. Be sure to prepare well for these events, and focus on showcasing your strengths and abilities as a player.

In conclusion, there are many reasons why you may not be receiving a college baseball offer, and it’s important to understand that many factors go into a coach’s recruiting decisions. If you’re not receiving offers, take an honest look at your game and identify areas where you can improve. Work hard to develop your skills, maintain a strong academic record, and showcase your abilities at camps and showcases. With dedication and persistence, you can increase your chances of receiving a college baseball offer and achieving your dreams of playing at the collegiate level.

Mark Seibel

Mark is a former D3 pitcher and a baseball adviser who has helped hundreds of high school athletes achieve their dreams